Msgr. Joseph C. McLoone has resigned as pastor of one of the largest parishes in the Philadelphia Archdiocese due to financial and personal improprieties.
The priest had taken a voluntary leave of absence as pastor of St. Joseph Parish in Downingtown in February, without public explanation. Msgr. Thomas Dunleavy was named parochial administrator weeks later.
Last weekend parishioners of St. Joseph’s learned that Msgr. McLoone was placed on administrative leave, imposed by the archdiocese. He tendered his resignation as pastor, which Archbishop Charles Chaput accepted.
[tower]
Details revealed that when he arrived at the parish as administrator in 2011, Msgr. McLoone set up an off-the-books bank account that November to accept some donations by parishioners, but not Sunday Mass collections. The account had swelled to $110,000 over six years.
Some $50,000 had been paid from the account over that time, and of that amount, Msgr. McLoone had taken $1,500 “for personal expenses of an inappropriate nature” concerning “relationships with adults” not involving members of the parish, nor children, according to a statement by archdiocesan spokesman Ken Gavin.
He did not elaborate on the nature of the relationships but indicated they are a violation of the Standards of Ministerial Behavior and Boundaries, rules of conduct for all church personnel, clergy and volunteers that the Philadelphia Archdiocese established in 2003.
It is not uncommon, though deemed improper, for some parishes to utilize accounts outside the established archdiocesan norms of accounting and review to accept personal donations for the payment of ordinary parish expenses.
Use of such accounts often represents an attempt to evade archdiocesan accounting procedures and lessen the amount a parish is assessed for support of centralized archdiocesan ministries — in effect, attempting to benefit the parish by sequestering funds from accountability.
The archdiocese prohibits such practices in its parishes, schools and institutions, and in fact this week continued to roll out a long-planned new set of accounting procedures designed to tighten parish accounting and prevent off-the-books money management.
St. Joseph’s, with 4,742 registered households, is the largest Catholic parish in Chester County and the third largest in the archdiocese. With its new church (built in 2013), a burgeoning school and Parish Religious Education Program (PREP) along with numerous programs and ministries, the $110,000 in a separate account likely represents a fraction of the parish’s finances.
Nevertheless, because “activity from this account was not reflected in regular reports reviewed with the parish finance council or provided to the archdiocese,” Gavin said in his statement, accounts such as the one at St. Joseph’s are seen as an improper business practice.
In Msgr. McLoone’s case, he was “the only signer on this account and he acted alone with respect to the account’s activity,” Gavin said.
The account was frozen last February and a review of the parish’s financial records was begun by personnel from the archdiocesan Office for Parish Services and Support, according to Gavin.
“Based upon that work, it appears that deposits to this account consisted of some donations as well as other revenue generated by the parish,” he said. “The archdiocese does not believe that Sunday collections, contributions to the parish capital campaign, or school and PREP tuition fees were deposited therein.”
While some of the expenditures show documentation as normal parish expenses, others raised concern, Gavin said.
[hotblock]
After Msgr. McLoone was questioned directly, he acknowledged the account and his personal use of its funds.
An investigation into the account continues because “there are still approximately $50,000 in expenditures and ATM withdrawals that need to be better substantiated or explained,” Gavin said, adding the priest has been asked to provide that information.
As the review continues,” further action will be considered including referral to law enforcement,” Gavin said.
He added the archdiocese “is pursuing full financial restitution” for St. Joseph’s “for the expenditures that have been acknowledged as inappropriate.”
The parish finance council also has advised Msgr. Dunleavy, who temporarily leads the parish, “to seek reimbursement for any additional amounts that cannot be appropriately explained or substantiated when this process is complete,” Gavin said.
Msgr. McLoone, 55, was ordained in 1988 for the Philadelphia Archdiocese and had served as parochial administrator of St. Joseph’s since February 2011, until being named pastor in December 2012.
He took over a parish that had been rocked by the arrest of its former pastor, Msgr. William J. Lynn, for his involvement as an administrator in the clergy sexual abuse scandal in Philadelphia.
Although his 2012 conviction for endangering the welfare of a child was overturned in 2015, Msgr. Lynn served most of his three-year sentence in state prison. The Philadelphia District Attorney intends to retry his case, perhaps this year.
PREVIOUS: Archbishop Chaput announces clerical changes
NEXT: Neumann U lauds Penn Mutual’s support of rugby
Bitter disappointment for all of us. Where do we go from here?
As a parishioner of St. Joe’s and having had the pleasure of knowing Monsignor Mcloone I have to say that the good in him far outweighs this misjudgment. I really wish this had never even come to light. It is one thing to harm a child… those individuals deserve the wrath of heaven and earth but based on what it seems went on here I think forgiveness is in order. I wish the church had used better judgment over the years and taken care of the individuals in their care. We have lost trust in the church and our priests so when they deviate at all our minds automatically are suspicious and fear the worst. I don’t feel that Mcloone deserved this public tarring and feathering (I know others disagree) he is a good person who made some… human errors. If you are reading this Mcloone know that many of us don’t harbor any ill feelings and are wishing the best for you. We are really truly praying for your health and happiness and are sorry you are going through this difficult time. The good you have done far outweighs this… far outweighs.
There is a reason that churches are not allowed to have separate accounts that there is only one signer on – the temptation to commit evil is too great! How he could set up an “off the books” account after the last pastor left under dubious circumstances is incredibly bad judgment. So sad.
Each individual, lay or clergy, is a complicated combination of good and bad. We all make decisions others second guess and they always do. While I do not know how or why this happened, I know one thing as a parishioner of this parish for over 30 years, Monsignor Mc Loone was one of the best sheperds we’ve had. I will always be greatful to him for his Christlike pastoral care. May God carry you and us through this difficult time.
Totally agree Harriet! He is the best pastor and Shepard I have known. May God and the people of St. Joe’s forgive any wrong doings.
There is no deception like self deception! It appears that an otherwise good pastor opened up an off the book’s account for a good reason – giving the Msgr the benefit of the doubt – and soon finds himself collecting personal dividends from that account. Perhaps he had every intention of repaying money taken. He stole from his parishioners. Men are able to rationalize virtually anything when they first give in to the serpent’s hisss – “It’s okay…”
We are all frail men! May he recover his prayer life.
I’m not saying what he did was right, but I’m not going to judge him. He’s a good man from a good family. What I will do though is pray for him.
Msgr. needs our prayers as all our priests and seminarians. This is a difficult world to live in and that path is straight and narrow and he as well as all of us are human and do fall. Only problem is that those in leadership have it become part of the daily news. We all need to extend forgiveness and mercy which God so willingly gives us. Blessings Msgr.
What is going on. I say this not as a critic but as someone bewildered by the growing number of clergy who seemed to have lost their way. Embezzlement, illegal drugs, boundary issues, secret accounts, this is getting to be all too common. This is the third Pastor removed that I can recall in the past several months. It’s bad enough to hear the sniping from the critics but it’s disheartening to try and defend this indefensible behavior.
Joe, don’t you know the devil temps those closest to God. He’s at work always.
I’m sorry but he is a good guy and a good priest. If he needs some money to get the AD off his back I will gladly give. Again, a good guy.