No one saw it coming.
The two best teams in Catholic League baseball met each other in the Catholic League championship May 26 at Immaculata University. La Salle was the regular-season champion with an 11-1 record whose only loss was against second-place Archbishop Carroll.
Both teams were loaded in every area. Surely this would be a game – probably a pitcher’s duel – decided in the late innings.
La Salle 10, Archbishop Carroll 0. So much for predictions making sense on paper.
“I couldn’t believe it,” said senior winning pitcher Joe Miller. “It couldn’t have gone any better.”
After dodging a shaky top of the first inning, the Explorers exploded for seven runs in the bottom half, and the first out necessitated a great throw from junior Carroll centerfielder Tyler Kehoe that nabbed senior Eric Marasheski at the plate. A surreal 13 hitters came to bat and hoarded five singles, four walks, a hit batter, and a wild pitch that negated a strikeout. Any suspense was basically muted right there and then.
The only thing left for La Salle was to pitch well, play solid defense, and come up with three more runs to enforce the 10-run mercy rule.
Miller did the first part by giving up only three hits and three walks while striking out eight. He avoided problems in the first, second, and fifth innings when the Patriots (17-6 overall) put two runners on base but could not cash in.
Playing with a seven-run lead has its advantages.
“Just pitch to contact and let your fielders do the rest,” said Miller. “To do what we did in the first inning was huge.”
La Salle (20-3), which takes on Public League champ Frankford in the city title/District 12 final Friday afternoon, June 1, finished with 12 hits. Every starter had at least one hit and all but one scored a run.
Senior first baseman Brian Schaub ended the game in the fifth inning when his single scored Marasheski (2 for 4, 2 runs batted in, run scored) from third.
“It was a team effort,” said fourth-year La Salle coach Kyle Werman, celebrating his first CL title, La Salle’s ninth overall, and the program’s first since 2013. “We just had guys putting together good at bats and Joe was pitching great.”
The only players to contribute multiple hits were Marasheski and the Cossetti brothers, Anthony and Andrew. The senior fraternal twins made a combined eight plate appearances and produced five singles, three walks, three runs scored, and two runs batted in.
Both being able to share the Catholic League championship together was obviously very special.
“I can’t really explain it,” said Andrew, the Catholic League’s Offensive Player of the Year and a catcher who will play at St. Joseph’s University. “We’ve been playing together all of our lives. We’ve obviously won some championships in travel baseball in the summer, but nothing like this. It’s really hard to explain.”
Anthony, a Naval Academy-bound outfielder who is 16 minutes older than Andrew and joked that he reminds his younger brother of his status “every single day,” felt similarly.
“It’s an entirely different experience,” he said, “and I couldn’t be more happy than to do it with my brother.”
Standing close by were Cossetti’s parents, Tony and Taunya. Tony Cossetti graduated from La Salle in 1989 but not before winning the Catholic League championship in 1988 as a leadoff hitter under Joe Parisi, who amassed four CL titles and retired from coaching after the Explorers captured the 2014 PIAA state crown.
“It’s really surreal,” said Tony. “I’m just so proud of them for all the hard work they put in. They’re such good kids. I always tell them to play with class and to play the game the right way. To come out and play the way they did, I’m just really proud of them.
“The most important part for me is to play La Salle baseball. Joe Parisi instilled it into us and I try to tell them that this is what Coach Parisi taught me. There’s a certain way you play La Salle baseball and these guys all got it. My kids got it. The teammates got it. Seeing them play with class is the most important thing.”
Parisi, the longtime athletic director at La Salle, stood for the twins’ baptisms and confirmations.
“When Tony and Taunya asked me to be the godfather of the boys, I was proud to say yes,” said Parisi. “Knowing the type of people they are, I consider it to be an honor to be around Andrew and Anthony as well as their parents. It has been very special to see them grow so much spiritually, academically, and socially on a daily basis during their four years at La Salle.
“During their years at La Salle, I had to remain relatively ‘neutral’ when it came to baseball. In reality I am a big fan of theirs and look forward to being able to outwardly root for them as they move on to college and beyond.”
Beating Carroll also allowed the Explorers to avenge a 5-4 setback against the Patriots on April 30.
“It always feels good to come back and win against a team you lost to earlier in the year,” said Andrew. “They’re really good competitors and came out to play. We just played our game and luckily we came out on top.”
“On any given day that could be an entirely different ballgame, and today it’s not really luck because we trained for this the entire year,” he said. “Can’t put words to it.”
Three would suffice: Catholic. League. Champion.
John Knebels can be reached at Jknebels@gmail.com or on Twitter @johnknebels.
Help keep Catholic media free, support CatholicPhilly.com
You may have noticed “pay walls” greeting you when you visit the websites of newspapers and magazines, both large and small. These mechanisms allow you to read a few articles for free before you’ve got to pay an annual fee if you want to see more.
You won’t find a pay wall on CatholicPhilly.com because we’re more than a news organization. We’re informing, inspiring and forming readers in the Catholic faith every day through the news, features and commentaries that we post on this site and share across social media.
It costs money to provide high-quality coverage of the local Catholic communities we primarily serve, while also distributing national and world news of interest to Catholics, plus the orthodox teachings of the Catholic faith.
Help us in this mission by making a single gift of $40, $50, $100, or more. Your gift will strengthen the fabric of our entire Catholic community.
Make your donation by check:
222 N. 17th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Or by credit card here: