PHILADELPHIA – Going to the Palestra.

In the two Philadelphia Catholic League semifinals played at Conwell-Egan High School on Feb. 22, eight different players were interviewed after their respective victories. Unprompted, every one of them mentioned that heralded phrase.

Going to the Palestra.

On Feb. 28, the league’s two top seeds will meet in what promises to be a classic PCL final. Top-seed Archbishop Carroll, which finished a perfect 10-0 during the regular season and stopped eight-seed West Catholic in the quarterfinals, defeated five-seed Neumann-Goretti in the semis, 50-35.

Two hours later, two-seed Cardinal O’Hara dispatched defending league champion and three-seed Archbishop Wood, 55-48.

O’Hara’s only league loss was at Archbishop Carroll, 49-39, on Feb. 1. The Lions finished 9-1 and then handled seven-seed St. Hubert in the semifinals.

Senior Grace O’Neill’s 28 points, 11 rebounds, and three assists paced Archbishop Carroll’s 50-35 PCL semifinal win over Neumann-Goretti. (Photo by John Knebels)

In Carroll’s win, senior Grace O’Neill was magnificent. Her 28 points, 11 rebounds, three assists and one block included 13 free throws, eight of them in a pivotal fourth quarter. Junior Taylor Wilson added 12 points, 15 rebounds, and four blocks. Senior Maggie Grant drilled two key three-pointers along with three rebounds and two assists.

“I’m really proud of the girls,” said Carroll coach Renie Shields. “They stepped up when they had to step up. It gives the girls a chance to go down to the Palestra and see what it’s actually like. There’s nothing like it. I always tell the girls – it’s the best feeling you’re ever going to get.”

The Patriots were forced to play most of the game without key guard Brooke Wilson. The second-team All-Catholic sophomore is one of Carroll’s best defenders, and her energy level is unmatched. But with 6:11 left in the second quarter, Wilson rolled her ankle and lay on the gym floor for seven scary minutes. She was able to hobble to the bench, but she was unable to join her teammates on the court.

Her status in the upcoming final is undecided.


“We just pulled together and continued to push through,” said O’Neill. “We knew Brooke’s assignments. We focused on picking up areas that we could, and we just stayed positive.”

Whenever Neumann-Goretti got close behind seniors D’Ayzha Atkinson (15 points, 11 rebounds), senior Mihjae Hayes (11 points), and sophomore Brooke Barnes (four points, seven rebounds, two blocks), O’Neill steadied the waters.

“I definitely think with experience I’m calmer now,” said O’Neill. “I wasn’t maybe when I was a freshman.”

Carroll outrebounded the Saints by 44 to 27.

“We knew how gritty they were and how scrappy they were on the boards,” said O’Neill. “The number one thing was boxing out and getting boards, and I feel we did a good job with that.”

The Patriots will face an O’Hara team that has won more titles (18) than any other Catholic League team. The second most? Archbishop Carroll, with 10.

With Wood senior and PCL Most Valuable Player Ryanne Allen scoring 18 points and doing all she could to will the Vikings to victory, the Lions received balanced scoring from their five starters and held the Vikings to seven points in the third quarter.

“We knew we were in for a battle,” said O’Hara coach Chrissie Doogan. “We had a couple of good days of practice leading up to it, so I felt good. I thought our seniors stepped up late, played some defense, and got some rebounds.

“They just didn’t let us lose.”

The key senior was Maggie Doogan, who doubles full-time as the coach’s daughter. Doogan finished with 17 points, seven rebounds, four steals, and three assists. On her last point – a free throw in the closing seconds – Doogan reached 1,000 career points.

“This was such a fun game to play, but we’re not done,” said Doogan. “We still have to finish this off at the Palestra and get the job done. With this group of girls, going to the Palestra is so special. We all play great together and are super close off the court, so being able to get this opportunity is amazing; just have to finish the job.

“Scoring 1,000 is such a cool honor, and my teammates were so happy for me. It was great. I didn’t even know I got it until after the game, but it was a cool moment that I’m glad I got to experience.”

Freshman Molly Rullo scored a game-high 19 points to help Cardinal O’Hara upend Neumann-Goretti, 55-48, in a PCL semifinal. (Photo by John Knebels)

As well as O’Hara’s upperclassmen played, the Lions would not have emerged victorious had it not been for freshman Molly Rullo.

Driving to the basket like a veteran, Rullo tallied a game-high 19 points. Rullo credited O’Hara players such as Doogan, senior Annie Welde (five points, five rebounds), senior Sydni Scott (seven points, five rebounds), and junior Bridget Dawson (five points, two rebounds) for her quick development into a second-team All-Catholic.

“They have made me very comfortable from the start,” said Rullo. “They have helped me a lot.”

Best part of her freshman year?

“Going to the Palestra,” said Rullo.

Of course.


Contact John Knebels at or on Twitter @johnknebels.