WASHINGTON (CNS) — Republican candidate Donald Trump’s run for the White House is putting the efforts by the Republican Party to defend and advance the many “noble causes” it has promoted in its history “in grave danger,” said an open letter to Catholics published March 7 in the National Review.
“Donald Trump is manifestly unfit to be president of the United States. His campaign has already driven our politics down to new levels of vulgarity,” said the letter from two prominent Catholics, Robert George and George Weigel.
“His appeals to racial and ethnic fears and prejudice are offensive to any genuinely Catholic sensibility,” they wrote in their “appeal to our fellow Catholics and to all men and women of goodwill.
[hotblock]
George is the McCormick professor of jurisprudence at Princeton University. Weigel is distinguished senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center and holds its William E. Simon chair in Catholic studies.
“There is nothing in his campaign or his previous record that gives us grounds for confidence that he genuinely shares our commitments to the right to life, to religious freedom and the rights of conscience, to rebuilding the marriage culture, or to subsidiarity and the principle of limited constitutional government,” they said.
National Review, based in Washington, is the conservative magazine founded by William F. Buckley. The letter from George and Weigel included signatures from at least 35 others well-known in legal, academic, public policy circles as well as at think tanks.
George and Weigel said that the Republican Party — while “imperfect, like all human institutions, but serviceable” has in recent decades been a vehicle “for promoting causes at the center of Catholic social concern in the United States.”
Those causes include “providing legal protection for unborn children, the physically disabled and cognitively handicapped, the frail elderly, and other victims of what St. John Paul II branded ‘the culture of death.'”
The party also has defended religious freedom “in the face of unprecedented assaults by officials at every level of government who have made themselves the enemies of conscience”; worked to rebuild “our marriage culture” based on the “sound understanding” that marriage is between one woman and one man; and made strong efforts to re-establish “constitutional and limited government, according to the core Catholic social-ethical principle of subsidiarity.”
“There have been frustrations along the way, to be sure; no political party perfectly embodies Catholic social doctrine,” they said. “But there have also been successes, and at the beginning of the current presidential electoral cycle, it seemed possible that further progress in defending and advancing these noble causes was possible through the instrument of the Republican Party.”
George and Weigel acknowledged that Trump “speaks to issues of legitimate and genuine concern” and said they understand that as a result, many people, including Catholics, have been attracted to his campaign.
Some of those issues, they said, are “wage stagnation, grossly incompetent governance, profligate governmental spending, the breakdown of immigration law, inept foreign policy, stifling ‘political correctness’ — for starters.”
“There are indeed many reasons to be concerned about the future of our country, and to be angry at political leaders and other elites,” George and Weigel said.
But they urged Catholics and other voters to consider other Republican candidates who are “far more likely” than Trump “to address these concerns, and who do not exhibit his vulgarity, oafishness, shocking ignorance, and — we do not hesitate to use the word — demagoguery.”
George and Weigel did not name the others still in the running for the Republican nomination: U.S. Sens. Ted Cruz, of Texas, and Marco Rubio, of Florida, and Ohio Gov. John Kasich.
Trump’s record and his campaign “show us no promise of greatness; they promise only the further degradation of our politics and our culture,” George and Weigel said.
“We urge our fellow Catholics and all our fellow citizens to reject his candidacy for the Republican presidential nomination by supporting a genuinely reformist candidate,” they added.
George and Weigel also pointed to Trump’s talk on the stump of ordering U.S. military personnel “to torture terrorist suspects and to kill terrorists’ families.” The writers pointed out such actions are condemned by the Catholic Church.
Such policies, they added, “would bring shame upon our country.”
On the campaign trail, Trump had said that as commander in chief, he “would order the military” to carry out torture and override the fact the U.S. military is not duty-bound to carry out unlawful orders. But after facing scathing criticism of his views on how to fight terrorism, CNN reported March 4 that Trump had reversed himself and said he would not order the military to violate international law.
PREVIOUS: Backers of Oregon’s new historic minimum wage say it’s matter of justice
NEXT: Catholic schools not doing enough for Latino Catholics, report shows
The only “Catholic” reason to vote for Trump would be to vote for “a lesser of two evils.” However, this exception is based on one being able to ascertain, in a responsible way, if a candidate really is a lesser of two evils. This is impossible to do with a sociopath. Let me repeat: This is impossible to do with a sociopath. Hilary may be pro death culture, but by his history, Donald Trump is not only pro death, but still currently possesses all the traits of a narcissistic sociopath, with no conscience or true empathy for anyone. He does not support his new “pro life” position with educated, reasoned pro life arguments, and in fact, thinks his sister who supports partial birth abortion would make an ideal Supreme Court nominee. In fact, Trump viciously hates the most innocent, weakest and most vulnerable among us. He makes fun of the handicapped, those who are not, in his words, “superstars”, those who do not look like “superstars”, and would impose the death penalty on the innocent wives and children of terrorists, who are already put in double binds, oppressed and offered for sacrifice by Muslim terrorist’s own culture. The lesser of two evils? I think Catholics should band together to support a third party, or there will nobody to defend us when the powers that be come for us.
The Catholic Church needs to become less a Republican “mouth piece”! I am not a Republican and will never be one and yes a proud Democrat, I am! in your ugliness, make the worse of that you can. At 62 years old, I wonder when the church will see the issues of our country being more than one issue…Abortion. While I may agree on the “morality” of it, I can also desire with out conflict, the other aspects the “morality” of taking care of those who are living here and now! And please don’t insult me by saying how much the Republicans have done, unless you mean the incorrect propaganda of who the undeserving are that get assistance, while they cut pack on programs and assistance or threaten to.
The Church needs to be more balanced and at best get out of the Republican party!
And as far as Donald Trump supporters, you are way, way off track. Stop admiring him for who you think he is and listen to this man real is!!! He doesn’t share any values with any decent human being of any religion, party or any country!
I hope the Catholic Nuns in our Parish would remove OBAMA bumper stickers on their vehicles. Anybody writing about the Churchs agressive role in passing OBAMACARE that threatens our religious liberties? The Church accepting Millions of Dollars managing ILLEGAL not law abiding citizens. This is utter Chaos. I lived in 9 countries I never worked or lived without a Visa and fingerprinting.I had to pay taxes and never was eligible for any local benefits. Even when I invested in my own company.
Maybe the Church should step away from Politics. They can’t even teach the FAITH properly. Bring Back apologetics to the High School curriculum. I had 16 years of Catholic Schooling. On My Final Class of my Catholic education. A Rabbi who I invited to talk on Faith I learned More on his 45 minutes turned into 3 hours than I did in my formative years!
Trump represents the disgust that people have for politicians. I do not agree with everything he says but he is a breath of fresh air. Catholics in the USA are wimps. They have been indoctrinated by liberalization.
Hard to understand why these pious sounding high profile Catholics were not advocating the same thing against Barack Obama when he was running and against Hillary Clinton right now.
Also why are these so called concerned Catholics seemingly more concerned about Mr. Trump’s public image and likeability than with his moral character? They seem like a bunch of angry religious hypocrites.
Donald Trump is far from perfect, but from a Catholic morality perspective his current positions against intrinsic moral evils seems right in line with Catholic teaching and also in line with his fellow Republican candidates. So what’s the beef? That Trump can’t be elected or trusted?
My question is how are you so sure? And what makes you think the other Republican candidates will be more trustworthy and electable?
And most importantly, what about Hilary Clinton? If Mr. Trump does get the nomination are Catholics then supposed to vote for her?
I think the bigger issue here is why Catholics are not being clearly told that as Catholics they can never support or vote for intrinsic evilness. That this is a morally required litmus test that every Catholic must apply against all political candidates before making their voting decision.
What the leaders of the Catholic Church are really afraid of is after we take the country back we will than take our Church back from the perverts and those who hide them. Those leaders know that we will not stop until we have both our country and Church back and they are in prison!!!!!!
This is an outrageous–though predictable– response from neoconservative George Weigel, who never met a war he didn’t love, and Robert George, a good man but unfortunately allied with bloodthirsty neocons. If America doesn’t shake the neoconservative death-grip we are done. Mr. Trump is our only hope.
It is essential for Catholics to wake up and repudiate neoconservatism and neoliberalism– doctrines which are driving America into the ground. Catholics! Wake up to the social and economic teachings of the Holy Church and be no longer fooled by these delusional dead ends.
How can you tolerate a man who is vulgar,confrontational ,divisive and insulting. He is full of empty promises ( empty of detail ). Can you trust him with our nuclear forces when he “takes down” IS & North Korea? Will he intern Muslim Americans, ala, Japenese Americans in WWII? Or begin mass deportation of illegal immigrants who have lived here for most of their young adult years, having been employed by Mr Trumt’s business friends.
He’s lead the campaign to new lows and opened the door of the White House to Mrs Clinton. She’s a poor choice but he’s worse.
There’s nothing neo about Weigel & George. The only neo I can see is Mr Trump, or maybe he’s nothing but a billionaire, having a grand old time.
Tom Owens
PS He claims to think highly of veterans ( of which he is not one ) and mocks Senator McCain … Disgraceful.
If all Catholics dump Trump, are we, Catholics< against the Americans who vote for Trump? So far, Trump received many votes @ many Primaries and Caucus which represent people who support Trump. If dumped Trump, are we Catholics think that all Trump's supporters are stupid and we, as Catholics, are smarter and more patriotic than them?
At least, Trump did not receive any financial supports from others, thus, Trump does not need to follow any financial supporters' request/demand. If Trump is a financial achiever, he would be an US President-achiever. We, Catholics, do not need to agree with Trump 100%. We, Catholics need to involve, help Trump
to be a President who run our country accordingly to our Catholic teaching.
We, Catholics need to vote for Trump, NOT because Trump is the best candidate, but because we, Catholics, do not want to vote for Clinton who is a duplicate of Obama and Sanders, a Communist, nor we want to vote for other Republicans who received fund from supporters, who will not be independent financially and very weak when dealing with the Communists, China, Russia and ISiS.
Mary
Sacramento/CA
Well, these three gentlemen, Messrs. Trump, Weigel and George, have at least one thing in common, don’t they? Aren’t they are former Democrats? One amazing thing to me is that CatholicPhily.com published this specific “do this, don’t do that; vote for him; don’t for him” — with reference nformation solidly grounded in 6 to 9-month old magazine articles — with an apparent complete lack of fear of losing tax exemption status?!
I wonder if these two gentlemen spoke out as vigorously against supporting the most anti-Catholic politician in my lifetime- Barack Obama; I suspect not. Trump does have significant faults; he also has a track record of business success and some very good ideas about governing. Most importantly he is not part of the Republican establishment. I might vote for him, I might not. Not having seem the Catholic establishment speak out in 2008 and 2012 against the most pro-abortion Democrat candidate, I am frustrated to read anti-Trump articles. And in case you wonder, I am a Catholic-lifelong.